Post by Masaki on Nov 6, 2007 18:04:37 GMT -5
I can use this to get out of hot water over the Naomi vote. Singe cannot accept the fact that Cain would try to distance himself from Beverly while claiming that I tried helping her by voting Naomi.
Fact 4. The tiebreaker
Beverly and Cain approached Gordy with the following plan in episode 5: Pass the tiebreaker exclusively between the 3 of them during the game.
Cain passed his tiebreaker onto Beverly as planned shortly before exile. He did not pass it onto another Beverly voter, in case he had doubts about Beverly. He gave it directly to Beverly. As Adelaide pointed out earlier, you'd have to be a huge idiot or a spy to agree to pass the tiebreaker on to an investigated and confirmed spy.
Beverly said shortly before exile that the vote count was expected to be 8-8. She, and Cain if she talked to him (they were both online before exile), clearly knew that there was a strong chance the tiebreaker would have to be used.
1) It'd be suicide as a spy to give the tiebreaker to Bev--once she turned up a spy you'd obv be the next target. Too blatant.
2) If the vote was coming down between two teammates, BOTH investigated, why put your neck on the line to save either one of them? The smart play is clearly to put a million miles between yourself and them.
Not buying the tiebreaker argument--two trads were caught by inv and their strategy became:
A) protect the remaining uninvestigated member
B) ...
C) ...
Z) survival of Bev/Naomi
MORE ON THIS!!! Singe also claimed, the day before the Trial, that my vote on Naomi was not indicative of whether or not I have ties with the Traditionalist Spies.
singe said:
candy said:
Fact 4. The tiebreaker
Beverly and Cain approached Gordy with the following plan in episode 5: Pass the tiebreaker exclusively between the 3 of them during the game.
Cain passed his tiebreaker onto Beverly as planned shortly before exile. He did not pass it onto another Beverly voter, in case he had doubts about Beverly. He gave it directly to Beverly. As Adelaide pointed out earlier, you'd have to be a huge idiot or a spy to agree to pass the tiebreaker on to an investigated and confirmed spy.
Beverly said shortly before exile that the vote count was expected to be 8-8. She, and Cain if she talked to him (they were both online before exile), clearly knew that there was a strong chance the tiebreaker would have to be used.
1) It'd be suicide as a spy to give the tiebreaker to Bev--once she turned up a spy you'd obv be the next target. Too blatant.
2) If the vote was coming down between two teammates, BOTH investigated, why put your neck on the line to save either one of them? The smart play is clearly to put a million miles between yourself and them.
Not buying the tiebreaker argument--two trads were caught by inv and their strategy became:
A) protect the remaining uninvestigated member
B) ...
C) ...
Z) survival of Bev/Naomi
adelaide said:
Singe you're not taking into account Bev's Village Decoy role that had half the burg believing her so it was not a risk. Bev and Naomi clearly were trying desperately to save themselves and it could have meant risking Cain too.MORE ON THIS!!! Singe also claimed, the day before the Trial, that my vote on Naomi was not indicative of whether or not I have ties with the Traditionalist Spies.