|
Post by Judge Sam on Nov 10, 2007 23:29:09 GMT -5
11:59 PM CST Saturday.
|
|
Summer
Summer
Cold Catcher (achoo!)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Summer on Nov 10, 2007 23:49:37 GMT -5
#1: Rank everyone else in the game from 1 to 14 in terms of how sure they are of themselves and their opinions. Rank as 1 the person who is the MOST sure of what they know. This person has a firm opinion on all events that take place in the game and will tell you what it is. They lay the facts out on the line and analyze them. Rank as 14 the person who is the most confused and doesn't even know what they themselves think. This person doesn't have any opinion on what's been happening recently, and if they do, they change it all the time. They are constantly saying "I'm not sure really" and "I have no idea" when asked to comment on people or events. Do not include yourself in the rankings.
1. Singe 2. Candy 3. Damon 4. Bunni 5. Masaki 6. Abrams 7. Faizah 8. Adelaide 9. Kip 10. Hannah 11. Zander 12. Leon 13. Cain 14. Johan
|
|
Summer
Summer
Cold Catcher (achoo!)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Summer on Nov 10, 2007 23:52:49 GMT -5
#2: Rank everyone else in the game from 1 to 14 in terms of how long you think they will last in the game. Rank as 1 the person who you think is going to last the longest - they won't be Imprisoned or Exiled any time soon. This person is not a threat to the Spies and is not suspected as a Spy. They are the most likely to be around awhile. Rank as 14 the person who you think is on their way out next. This person is most likely to be eliminated from the game soon. Either they are due to be Exiled or due to be Imprisoned. Do not include yourself in the rankings.
1. Bunni 2. Kip 3. Zander 4. Abrams 5. Hannah 6. Faizah 7. Johan 8. Masaki 9. Damon 10. Leon 11. Adelaide 12. Singe 13. Candy 14. Cain
|
|
Summer
Summer
Cold Catcher (achoo!)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Summer on Nov 10, 2007 23:54:42 GMT -5
#3: Rank everyone else in the game from 1 to 14 in terms of how much they are holding back their true opinions and feelings to avoid being eliminated. Rank as 1 the person who you KNOW is not sharing their true thoughts and feelings either to avoid pissing off Citizens or avoid pissing off Spies. This person is hemming and hawing and hedging their bets - they are scared of doing something that will get them eliminated so they hold back. Rank as 14 the person who is the most genuine and being themselves. This person is not holding back at all - they are saying exactly what they think and they are being themselves. They do not care what other people think or if other people may want to eliminate them - they just act genuine and like themselves all the time. Do not include yourself in the rankings.
1. Masaki 2. Faizah 3. Leon 4. Damon 5. Cain 6. Bunni 7. Johan 8. Abrams 9. Hannah 10. Adelaide 11. Singe 12. Kip 13. Zander 14. Candy
|
|
|
Post by Judge Sam on Nov 12, 2007 4:39:54 GMT -5
comments are necessary - please complete
|
|
Summer
Summer
Cold Catcher (achoo!)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Summer on Nov 12, 2007 16:41:52 GMT -5
Really? I thought they were optional.
I'll do it later tonight, Sam.
|
|
Summer
Summer
Cold Catcher (achoo!)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Summer on Nov 12, 2007 21:21:45 GMT -5
Question 1:
For someone who's awfully sure of himself, Masaki sure says "I have no idea" a lot. I think he pretends to be uncertain when he's trying to manipulate someone into taking action for him. Another person who seems to be faking uncertainty is Leon. At the beginning of the game he was all about "Dang, I am so smart!" but we've never heard him offer an actual opinion of his own. He's pretending to be stupid as a cover. I think they are both spies.
|
|
Summer
Summer
Cold Catcher (achoo!)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Summer on Nov 14, 2007 0:28:36 GMT -5
Question 2:
There are players here who will last for a very long time simply because they aren't playing the game. I would include Abrams, Damon, Leon, Summer, Johan, and Faizah in this group, They are easily defeatable opponents, so why remove them? Bandwagons are already developing for some other players, including Candy, Masaki, and Leon again; All the spies have to do is jump on the bandwagons. The spies have fully calculated their victory.
|
|
Summer
Summer
Cold Catcher (achoo!)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Summer on Nov 14, 2007 2:26:34 GMT -5
Question 3:
One of the biggest problems I have with Masaki is that he only comments on neutral facts and other people's comments. He holds his cards very close to his chest - that's why he always repeats what you said back to you (in different words) when you ask him for his opinion. He hides his own. Faizah is another player who withholds what she thinks. Her critique that accused her of hopping on bandwagons and never leading a vote is completely accurate. She has opinions, but she's probably exercising them behind the scenes as a spy. Singe wants to appear as if he's withholding his opinions, but I don't think he has many to offer (and I think he's a spy too).
Players like Candy and Adelaide who tell you exactly what they think without fear are a breath of fresh air. They are the idea initiators and that's incredibly helpful.
|
|