Hunting the Last Spy

[Kate (Damon)]

Confessional Notes

Leon:

(As of Nov 16) Leon+++++

Speaking of that thread.. it does appear as highly suspcicious that people suddenly think it's a poor idea to target Leon when it was the same reason they targetted Cain. A mold does not make a Citizen and anyone can fake fitting into a mold if it suited them. I think that they;re grasping at straws or trying to protect one of their own. My guess? Leon and Candy are working together as the last Orthos.
Leon+++
Candy+++
Hannah++
Summer+

(Nov 16)

Also - Leon should have earlier ticks for the whole bait and switch by Angie during conversations that regarded him. Sorry if I mised that on the tick sheet. Bah.

(Nov 16)

Hannah:

(As of Nov 16) Hannah+++++++

Hannah has started to get on my nerves with her entire paranoia bit about the last vote. She can't let it go. She only got 4 votes and it really wasn't that big of a deal but she's spazzing out all over the board and I want to tell her to just calm down because it's doing no one any good. Right now she seems a little fidgety, definitely jumpy and is starting to look a little panicky. All signs to indicate that she could possibly be a Spy...
Hannah+

(Oct 17)

I'm not really a fan of Summer for any number of reasons but primarily because she rubs me the wrong way but her line in "Summer's government File" (Reply #7) about how Hannah tends to accuse people with 'poor reasoning' really caught my attention. Thinking about it I tend to see Hannah as a bit of a hypocritical player - she gets all upset and self righteous about becoming a target during the last vote but at the same time she's very quick to try and make targets out of other people. It feels a bit scummy...
Hannah+

(Oct 17)

There's a hugely antagonistic vibe going on throughout the Burg. Instead of trying to work together everyone is becoming more and more fractioned. Accusations are becoming more and more rampant and it's no longer a friendly place to be. It's honestly like a pack of rabid wolves as they try and sniff out their next nooning meal. The culprits? Those same people who feel entitlement within the game: Singe, Candy, Zander, Hannah.
Singe+
Candy+
Zander+
Hannah+

(Nov 14)

Candy's reaction to "Don't Drink the Kool-Aid" was over the top and precisely the reason I started suspecting her from Exile II onwards. She barely touches on any of the comments I made and only makes a fuss about the ones she didn't like. The level of immaturity could be an act or simply a cover and I'm leaning towards it bein a cover. I don't even have the patience to fight back on those topics simply because she isn't answeing them with the attention they deserve. Maybe I'll change my mind later today about that. Did it come as any surprise that Hannah was the first person to reply to an attack against Candy? It either makes her too trusting and loyal, too stupid or a Spy.
Candy++
Hannah+

(Nov 14)

Speaking of that thread.. it does appear as highly suspcicious that people suddenly think it's a poor idea to target Leon when it was the same reason they targetted Cain. A mold does not make a Citizen and anyone can fake fitting into a mold if it suited them. I think that they;re grasping at straws or trying to protect one of their own. My guess? Leon and Candy are working together as the last Orthos.
Leon+++
Candy+++
Hannah++

(Nov 16)

[Kate (Damon)]

Notes

A general note about defenses: I don't care what kind of crap you pull from your logs. You can alter those things with ease, any uneducated person has that ability. I haven't paid much attention to shared convesrations at all this game unless accompanied by some analysis and commentary. TL;DR.

Leon:

(+) Throws Faizah under the Bus to protect himself. Could be a Spyish move or could just be a true Cit. I'm more inclined to think that these 2 went after reach other for a reason - to try and prove themselves to be the last Spy standing.
(+) Faizah could have voted Leon in IX-1 but chose to vote Singe instead, all by herself. (Singe, "Faizah+Leon")
(+) Leon gave his investigation points to Gordy, as did Faizah and Angelica, in their attempt to manipulate Gordy. (Singe, "Faizah+Leon", Reply #4)
(+) Faizah's oops moment of replying straight to the Faizah+Leon thread instead of any others. This is a bit more circumstantial but it matters.
(+) Leon's reaction to Singe's 'fake' investigation
(+) Leon's continued and repeated promises to 'start doin some work' but never coming up with more than a simple defense.

Hannah:

(+) Hannah's early assessment of Faizah and Angelica as the likely Citizens. Faizah was non existent in the beginning of the game so that comes off as highly suspicions.
(+) Group dynamics including Hannah as a Spy alongside Angelica and Faizah (Candy, 'Faizah+Hannah', Reply #6)
(+) Hannah gave her points to Gordy, right after Ang did. Not subtle (Singe, 'Faizah+Hannah', Reply #10)

Other Information:

(-) That wont matter, however, and I will go....much thanks to Singe. Please take this into consideration after my (mis)exile. (Faizah, "Faizah+Leon", Reply #1): Confirms Singe as a Citizen, IMO.

[Kate (Damon)]

Zander:

(+) Overlooked Final Words of Ralph, where he points out Zander as a potential Spy
(+) Zander's close proximity to Candy has sat him in a good position to play the trusted role.
(+) There's not enough information to gather against him. When you think about his posts as a collective nothing stands out except for the Masaki catch (who was a Traditionalist).
(+) "Furthermore why had Zander suddenly let up on Masaki now that Cain is gone and another Exile is on the way? He was so sure in VIII but isn't addressing it in IX?" (Observation Thread, Nov 14)

[Kate (Damon)]

Post Analysis

ZANDER
Zander's last posts (most recent first):
1. Scheduling
2. XI Questions
3. Fluff
4. Fluff
5. Fluff
6. Fluff
7. Reply: Hannah Defense; referring to her evidence as circumstantial, lists example.
8. Fluff
9. Fluff
10. Reply: Faizah+Hannah; evidence against Hannah in form of a PM authored by Zander.
11. Reply: Only 28...; mentions Damon+Faizah being left off possible suspect list.
12. Scheduling
13. Fluff
14. Memories VII
15. Memories VIII
16. Memories III
17. Memories V
18. X Questions
19. Reply: Faizah+Leon; argueing against Damon's statement that Singe deserves all the credit.
20. Reply: Avoid hijacking..; advocating for peace on the board instead of petty arguements.
21. Reply: Faizah+Zander; notes that he pre-voted Faizah, that he didn't wait for the 'momentum'.
22. Reply: Penalties for..; explains why his alias was revealed.
23. Reply: Unsure - Pooling..; questions why Faizah never posted and asks how everyone voted in the poll.
24. Fluff
25. Fluff

LEON
Leon's last posts (most recent first):
1. Scheduling
2. Fluff
3. Reply: Adelaide's Dreams; confirms that he could only pick confessionals.
4. XI Questions
5. Fluff
6. Fluff
7. Memories V
8. Memories I
9. Memories IX
10. Fluff
11. Reply: Memories IX; questioning a statement made by Singe.
12. Reply: Faizah+Leon; defence, claims he never talked to the Orthos, Masaki a lot, Naomi/Bev a bit, Emma never.
13. Reply: Faizah+Leon; fluff declaration of not being a spy.
14. Reply: Faizah+Leon; defence reply concerning Singe post about questioning immunity.
15. Reply: Faizah+Leon; defence fluff, declares he never tried to talk to Angelica and he has no control over what she said about him.
16. Reply: Faizah+Leon; clarifies why he gave his points to Gordy.
17. Reply: Leon Defense...; lists each of his Spy suspicions for all the rounds until present (at time of the post), questions why he would work against a fellow Spy.
19. Reply: Leon Defense..; fluff declaration that he plans to prove he's not a Spy.
20. Reply: And It All...; fluff comment on why he hadn't posted, clarifies suspicious vs. campaigning.
21. Fluff
22. Reply: And It All..; analysis of the remaining Spy candidates.
23. X Questions
24. Scheduling
25. Fluff