Rankings Part 1 - How sure are you?

[Judge Sam]

#1: Rank everyone else in the game from 1 to 14 in terms of how sure they are of themselves and their opinions. Rank as 1 the person who is the MOST sure of what they know. This person has a firm opinion on all events that take place in the game and will tell you what it is. They lay the facts out on the line and analyze them. Rank as 14 the person who is the most confused and doesn't even know what they themselves think. This person doesn't have any opinion on what's been happening recently, and if they do, they change it all the time. They are constantly saying "I'm not sure really" and "I have no idea" when asked to comment on people or events. Do not include yourself in the rankings.

~ Confident and Collected ~

MOST: Candy
2. Singe
3. Summer
4. Zander
5. Adelaide
6. Masaki
7. Hannah
8. Kip
9. Faizah
10. Damon
11. Leon
12. Bunni
13. Johan
14. Cain
LEAST: Abrams

~ Confused and Conciliatory ~

[Judge Sam]

I think Adelaide and Singe best fit this category. Both of them are vocal and opinionated, and both of them tell you what they really think. Other players will talk in AIM, but when it comes to posting on the board, they hold back and let others do the dirty work, and only then will they post. Singe and Adelaide post and tell what they think of other players.


I don't calue Johans opinion, even if/when it is vague and no commital. He is too quiet for my liking...and it creeps me out. Also, Candy is a little too sure of her opinions. A clever cover up perhaps for something deeper?


Candy, Singe, Zander, and Hannah think they are players above and beyond the scope of us mere mortals. In their eyes, they are always right and that's all there is to it. Screw everyone else. Just listen to them and we'll be golden. Summer and Leon take a slightly less narcissistic approach. Adelaide, while she says a lot, is easily swayed in her ideas, which is why she is down lower. And I can't even remember the last time Damon, Faizah, Abrams, or Johan even had an opinion to be sure about.


Candy always seems so sure of herself. She's got an opinion about everything, and lets people know for sure what it is. Little bit of a big mouth, but it's mostly for the best.


Have you ever wondered why Singe is so confident and sure of himself all the time? Singe needs to be confident to plant false ideas and assumptions into our heads - the more he seems to believe his lies, the more we will too.


Candy fits but to some extent she's overconfident in her theories because some have gaping holes. She IS trying though.


Singe is by far the most certain of what he knows. Although, as a normal player, his opinions may change over time, he has a very straightforward idea for what he's looking for, and won't allow simple sympathetic talk to alter that. Candy is on a similar level, but unfortunately, she allows personal conflict to get in the way. A perfect example of this was how her vote for Bunni seemed to be somewhat centered around the fact that Bunni suspected her.


I think Candy definitely fits this category the best. Whether she is correct or not, she is always very confident with her decisions. She's a power player, whether spy or citizen.


On the uncertain side, players who seem to be hiding in the shadows are the ones who are basing their own opinions around other players. Typically they will not add any thoughts of their own to justify this, either.


This was a difficult ranking list since very few players are very sure of what they think, and the majority of players are either AWOL or are wishy washy, or change their minds all the time. Candy is an obvious choice as the most opinionated and she always uses facts to support her opinions. There are quite a few ppl who deserve the title as most confused, I'd say most prominently Cain and Adelaide who either change theories as often as they change socks, and/or have no evidence to back their arguments.
I think Candy best fits this because she has been very vocal and has also been very right. Everybody knows Candy's views on things when she wants them to be known.


Candy knows exactly what shes doing and who she suspects. Johan I never see much from him.


Everything Candy does is either completely accepted, or completely listend to. She has gotten to the position where no one suspects her because she's such a help. And I think thats her main defense. Cain really didnt have many opinions, and those he did really didnt make much sense. He wasnt sure of himself, and that made him a suspect too.

[Singe]

Have you ever wondered why Singe is so confident and sure of himself all the time? Singe needs to be confident to plant false ideas and assumptions into our heads - the more he seems to believe his lies, the more we will too.

I'm far from sure of myself. But I will speak my mind clearly so you all know where I stand, and so you can use my words to determine my alignment. Some people in this game think it's wise for them to hide their opinions so no one gets hurt. I think that approach will cause more problems than it avoids, because people who hide too much really look like Spies. Sorry, it's just my opinion. I don't know how else to evaluate you guys other than on your honesty and forthrightness.

To whoever posted this critique, you're wrong--I haven't lied other than bullshitting about the investigation. If you really think I'm trying to mislead, you're mistaken. More likely, you're a spy who knows you'll have to discredit me sooner or later. Good luck with that.

[Candy]

I'm surprised Leon's not dead last.

[Leon]

candy said:

I'm surprised Leon's not dead last.

That makes 2 of us.

[Abrams]

3 of us.