Post by Beverly on Oct 29, 2007 22:28:59 GMT -5
This message is FROM ZANDER. Faizah decided to give it to me. 
MESSAGE START:
Hey guys.
Hannah and I were talking this afternoon, and off the top of our heads we basically shared names of people we trust the most, or think are almost definitely citizens.
Hannah proposed Gordy, Faizah, Beverly, and Singe (In that order)
I agreed and proposed Candy and Cain, in that order.
Hannah agreed with Candy and somewhat agreed with Cain.
We have chosen to exclude Cain and Beverly from this private message because we want to keep this information secret... And they would probably take it public.
And obviously we trust one another or we wouldn't have been talking about this in the first place
Hannah and I greatly suspect that Naomi is a spy, BUT, if she does turn out to be a spy and everyone votes for her then we learn nothing.
However, if she turns out to be a spy and we can keep a voting block secret, it's possible that we find out some other spies (And no, this is not an Adelaide strategy, we both actually thought htis out and think it can work).
Here's what it needs to work.
We need all of you to let us know if you are on board or not with thinking Naomi is a spy. Singe, I know you can't vote for her but your opinion helps just as much.
We need all of you to STAY QUIET about this, or we may not catch other spies. No, the plan is not perfect and nothing is guaranteed to work. However, if we stay quiet about who we are voting, then the spies gain no inside information about the Naomi vote, and will quiet possibly vote elsewhere.
Basically we are gaining insight to voting strategy, which is one of the easiest ways to catch a spy IMO.
So, what do you need to do?
1. Don't talk to anybody about it (By it I mean the vote and this). If we are all truly citizens then we could have a citizen coalition on our hands and when kept secret, that can win the game for us. In addition to this, we genuinely think Naomi is a spy and it's possible to catch her spy partners in the act by keeping quiet.
2. Come up with an alternative suspect. For example, if Joe says "Hey, who ya votin for?", and you are voting for Naomi, do not say you are voting for Naomi, and do not say another hugely popular suspect like, I don't know, pick your favorite. Saying you are voting for someone like Leon (Just an example) when we have a majority for Naomi is great - the spies would definitely vote for Leon and we could help figure them out. Nobody needs to see we voted Naomi until the votes are revealed, basically, because as soon as the spies get wind, they could vote against her too and we again, learn nothing.
3. Be careful around those you trust that aren't included in this message... Cain and Bev were left out cause they have big mouths, and could easily demolish this spy trap.
4. Respond to everyone in the group with ideas or contributions you might have. If Hannah and my plan works... We could all very well win the game for the citizens with this plan.
Right now we outnumber all of the spies. I think it's time to show them we mean war.
:MESSAGE END
MESSAGE START:
Hey guys.
Hannah and I were talking this afternoon, and off the top of our heads we basically shared names of people we trust the most, or think are almost definitely citizens.
Hannah proposed Gordy, Faizah, Beverly, and Singe (In that order)
I agreed and proposed Candy and Cain, in that order.
Hannah agreed with Candy and somewhat agreed with Cain.
We have chosen to exclude Cain and Beverly from this private message because we want to keep this information secret... And they would probably take it public.
And obviously we trust one another or we wouldn't have been talking about this in the first place
Hannah and I greatly suspect that Naomi is a spy, BUT, if she does turn out to be a spy and everyone votes for her then we learn nothing.
However, if she turns out to be a spy and we can keep a voting block secret, it's possible that we find out some other spies (And no, this is not an Adelaide strategy, we both actually thought htis out and think it can work).
Here's what it needs to work.
We need all of you to let us know if you are on board or not with thinking Naomi is a spy. Singe, I know you can't vote for her but your opinion helps just as much.
We need all of you to STAY QUIET about this, or we may not catch other spies. No, the plan is not perfect and nothing is guaranteed to work. However, if we stay quiet about who we are voting, then the spies gain no inside information about the Naomi vote, and will quiet possibly vote elsewhere.
Basically we are gaining insight to voting strategy, which is one of the easiest ways to catch a spy IMO.
So, what do you need to do?
1. Don't talk to anybody about it (By it I mean the vote and this). If we are all truly citizens then we could have a citizen coalition on our hands and when kept secret, that can win the game for us. In addition to this, we genuinely think Naomi is a spy and it's possible to catch her spy partners in the act by keeping quiet.
2. Come up with an alternative suspect. For example, if Joe says "Hey, who ya votin for?", and you are voting for Naomi, do not say you are voting for Naomi, and do not say another hugely popular suspect like, I don't know, pick your favorite. Saying you are voting for someone like Leon (Just an example) when we have a majority for Naomi is great - the spies would definitely vote for Leon and we could help figure them out. Nobody needs to see we voted Naomi until the votes are revealed, basically, because as soon as the spies get wind, they could vote against her too and we again, learn nothing.
3. Be careful around those you trust that aren't included in this message... Cain and Bev were left out cause they have big mouths, and could easily demolish this spy trap.
4. Respond to everyone in the group with ideas or contributions you might have. If Hannah and my plan works... We could all very well win the game for the citizens with this plan.
Right now we outnumber all of the spies. I think it's time to show them we mean war.
:MESSAGE END
But you can still do some damage while you're still in. Keep in mind people will know you're a spy by the end of tomorrow. What you say is going to be completely investigated. Never defend or push too hard to suspect me or Masaki, because that looks suspicious for us. Try put doubt in people's minds about other people, IF it's possible.