Spy List

[Sherri]

Well of course, this Citizen confessional would not be complete without its own Spy List! Not only it keeps track of my suspicions, but it gives the Spies and the host something to laugh about after the game!

Now, I will do this after dinner.

[Sherri]

Let's see... I have talked to all of the cast and some of them in-depth. I think more or less I have an idea of who to suspect... or not.

Spy Activity Criteria:

• Not showing up for chats/ Short conversations.
  
• Empty posts.
  
• Shoving attention to others.
  
• Slipping up (?)
  
• Conveniently in the middle of attention. Not too quiet, not too outspoken.
  
• Trying too hard to look like a Cit.
  

Ranked in order of Spyishness

Separated into groups since Spies would scatter their kind into different playstyles.

[X] Likely Spy candidates
[?] Not enough info, might be misplaced.

Screaming Spies. Possibly, 3/4 to 4/4 of these are spies.
[X]Gordy: spies4Gordy
[X]Hannah: spies4Hannah
Martha: spies4Martha
[X]Lloyd: spies4Lloyd

Middle players. Just enough attention to slip by. Good enough activity to gather and manipulate information. Possibly 2,3,4,5 out of five are spies.
[X]Angelica: spies4Angelica
Johan: spies4Johan
[X]Lise: spies4Lise
[?]Madison: spies4Madison
[X]Summer: spies4Summer

The silent ones. The silent killers. Lots of them, but to be effective Spies, only 1/8 of these people is a spy. I'd exile the rest of them for being unhelpful.

[?]Candy: spies4Candy
Emma: spies4Emma
Grace: spies4Grace
Cain: spies4Cain
Damon: spies4Damon
Kiyoshi: spies4Kiyoshi
Leon: spies4Leon
[X]Ralph: spies4Ralph

(The smart ones? I'm suspecting 1/5 - 2/5 are spies. Or it would be too easy)
[X]Singe: spies4Singe
[X]Faizah: spies4Faizah
Naomi: spies4Naomi
Kip: spies4Kip
Masaki: spies4Masaki

The hotseat. These people have not been in other categories but have been raking up attention. At most one is a spy. Perhaps none.
[?X] Adelaide: spies4Adelaide
Abrams: spies4Abrams
Beverly: spies4Beverly
[?]Jeremiah: spies4Jeremiah

Wallflowers. Enough activity and fame but nothing significant. Seems not interested in strategy talk. No certainty...
Bunni: spies4Bunni
[?]Zander: spies4Zander




And the final list would be something like...

GORDY
HANNAH
LLOYD
ANGELICA
LISE
SUMMER
RALPH
SINGE
FAIZAH
ADELAIDE

Pick your poison.

[Sherri]

I may have nailed most of the Spies on the first try... so fixating on that (or not) I divide them into two groups:


GORDY
HANNAH
RALPH


ANGELICA
SUMMER
FAIZAH
ADELAIDE

Too many women on the second group? Maybe it was too soon to remove Singe? Or Kip?

[Sherri]

Well two spies down and three episodes later... time for an update!

New Criteria (Tenchi's favorite!): Vote wasting

TRADITIONALIST
Emma
GORDY
HANNAH
NAOMI/LEON/JOHAN
RALPH


ORTHODOXY
ANGELICA
FAIZAH
SUMMER/ADELAIDE


I still think there are more men, but they don't post as much as women do... So it is really hard to gather substantial evidence.

[Sherri]

Episode Nine... Lots of things happening. Candy just revealed she was the Fatemaker, while working with Zander.

TRADITIONALIST
EMMA
BEV
NAOMI/LEON/JOHAN
HANNAH/KIP
GORDY


ORTHODOXY
ANGELICA
FAIZAH
SUMMER/ADELAIDE

[Sherri]

During the Tiebreak

Episode Nine... Lots of things happening. Candy just revealed she was the Fatemaker, while working with Zander.

TRADITIONALIST
EMMA
BEV
NAOMI/LEON/JOHAN
MASAKI
GORDY


ORTHODOXY
ANGELICA
KIP
SINGE/ADELAIDE

[Sherri]

Looking back on my first few days, these Spies assumed that I will stay for at least one Exile and wanted to befriend me. Looking at the people with real roles, they behave differently from the way Singe is acting.

Both Johan and Candy were in the middle of everything, trying to see who they can trust, not sharing too much about themselves making people think they are just bitchy or half-inactives.

And there are these Spies... with the exception of Emma. One way or another, Bev, Naomi, Angelica and Faizah all attempted to make some form of alliance with me, perhaps assuming I'm going to be some power player come Ep. 2.

And we have to take note that the last Spy obviously has played brilliantly to this point. He/she would be too dumb to leave breadcrumbs behind every exile...

(The smart ones? I'm suspecting 1/5 - 2/5 are spies. Or it would be too easy)
[X]Singe: spies4Singe
[X]Faizah: spies4Faizah
Naomi: spies4Naomi
Kip: spies4Kip
Masaki: spies4Masaki

I guess it was too easy after all...

Singe is the only one that fits into it. His role is a Spy role and is made to appear to be like a Citizen role. Of course, Kip the innocent Citizen could just have thought Singe had a Cit role and Singe used it to confirm himself.

The thing is, the role description is crap and any spy would be able to fake any series of "protections" he/she needed. Shane in Spies three got to protect people -- for a big price. And Singe gets to do it for free?

Not to mention the inconsistency of his role. All roles Sam made for this game had some form of consistent pattern, Singe's doesn't.

Singe is the last Spy.

[Beverly]

U NEVER GOT MEEE BAWAHAHHAA

JUST LIKE I NEVER GOT TENCHI.. WELL IG OT HIM WHEN I WAS OUT BUT STILLL LOLL

[Sherri]

Yeah... I suck.

><

[Zander]

At least Tenchi never caught me and I never caught him

[Martha]

beverly said:

U NEVER GOT MEEE BAWAHAHHAA

JUST LIKE I NEVER GOT TENCHI.. WELL IG OT HIM WHEN I WAS OUT BUT STILLL LOLL

OMFG was Tenchi a spy?!!

[Sherri]

NO WAI!!!

><

Well maybe I could've done better if I was actually in the game... or maybe not.

[Adelaide]

You really suspected me huh?

[Sherri]

1. I thought the threads were trying to hide your unhelpfulness.
2. Your "I'm gonna write something here tomorrow" either:
- Doesnt materialize
- Contains useless information
3. I suck.